Good vs Evil
My single biggest criticism of the works of Tolkien is just that it is so obvious all throughout the story which entities are good and which are evil (I suppose with the single exception of Saruman, whose treachery is unknown toward the beginning). But everything is black and white. In Peter Jackson's portrayal, all the good guys are handsome or beautiful and all the bad guys are ugly and disfigured. This is a common problem in many TV shows and movies, particularly older ones or ones targeted to children. Real life is not that way. In real life we have people who seem good from one angle or another and might actually be doing something bad in secret, or perhaps the same actions seen as good by one party may be seen as evil by another. I was arguing with a stranger on Facebook yesterday and during that argument he stated "If you enter this country illegally, your freedom is irrelevant to us." Honestly, I was shocked by this declaration. Rights which apply to some people...